Greenlee 25 ft Steel Fish Tape Review: Budget Option with Trade-Offs

Greenlee has a reputation for professional-grade tools, but not every product in their lineup lives up to the brand name. The 25 ft steel fish tape (model 438-2X) is their entry-level option—and the mixed reviews from electricians suggest you get what you pay for. Here's an honest look at what this budget fish tape can and can't do.

Quick Verdict

At around $16, the Greenlee 25 ft steel fish tape is priced for DIYers and occasional use rather than professional daily work. The 1/4" steel provides decent stiffness for straight pulls, but the short length limits applications and the winding mechanism draws complaints. For simple residential pulls through open walls or attic spaces, it'll get the job done. For anything more demanding, consider stepping up to Klein, Southwire, or Greenlee's longer professional-grade options.

Who This Is For (And Who Should Skip It)

Ideal for:

• DIYers pulling speaker wire or security camera cables through walls
• Homeowners adding an outlet or running a single cable
• Occasional users who don't need daily durability
• Budget-conscious buyers needing a basic fish tape

Skip it if:

• You're a professional electrician or low voltage installer
• You need to navigate conduit with bends (too stiff)
• You pull wire daily and need reliable winding
• You work with runs longer than 20 feet regularly

Key Features

1/4" wide steel construction: The wide steel provides good stiffness for pushing through straight runs. This is wider than the typical 1/8" fish tapes, making it more rigid—helpful for pushing through loose insulation but less flexible around bends.

25-foot length: Sufficient for residential walls and short attic runs. For most in-home projects like adding an outlet, 25 feet covers typical room dimensions. Commercial work or longer runs will require a different tool.

Compact case: The green plastic housing is portable and stores easily. It's designed for the tape to wind onto an internal spool, though the mechanism has reliability issues according to user feedback.

USA-made Greenlee brand: Greenlee manufactures in seven US facilities and has a long history in professional tools. However, not all products meet the same quality standard, and this entry-level tape receives more criticism than their professional-grade options.

Real-World Performance

The Greenlee 25 ft tape works adequately for its intended purpose—simple residential pulls through open wall cavities or attic spaces. Users report success pulling CAT6 cable for security cameras and running wire through older homes with wood wool insulation where the stiff steel pushes through well.

The problems emerge with anything beyond basic use. The 1/4" steel is too stiff to navigate conduit bends—users report it won't even make it around a 45-degree corner without jamming. If your work involves EMT or any conduit with bends, this isn't the right tape.

The winding mechanism draws consistent criticism. Users report the tape catching on itself inside the case, making retrieval difficult. Some experienced plastic pieces breaking inside the winder after limited use. For a tool you'll use repeatedly, this unreliability is a significant concern.

The stiffness that helps push through insulation becomes a liability in walls with obstructions. The tape doesn't flex around obstacles—it stops. More flexible 1/8" tapes navigate tight spaces better.

At this price point, the trade-offs are expected. Budget fish tapes prioritize cost over refinement. For occasional DIY use where you need to pull a single cable, it'll work. For professional use where time is money and reliability matters, the frustration isn't worth the savings.

What Works (Pros)

• Budget price point under $20
• 25-foot length sufficient for most residential wall pulls
• 1/4" steel pushes through loose insulation effectively
• Compact case for easy storage
• USA-made by established brand
• Adequate for occasional DIY cable pulls

What Doesn't Work (Cons)

• Winding mechanism jams and catches frequently
• Too stiff for conduit with bends—won't navigate 45° corners
• Short 25 ft length limits professional applications
• Plastic components in winder can break
• 1/4" width sacrifices flexibility for stiffness
• Not built for daily professional use
• Mixed reliability reports undermine Greenlee brand trust

Specifications

Specification	Value
Model Number	438-2X
Length	25 feet
Width	1/4 inch
Material	Steel
Case	Green plastic
Country of Origin	USA
Conductivity	Conductive (steel)

Better Alternatives to Consider

If you're a professional or do regular cable work, consider these instead:

Klein Tools 56005 (50 ft): The go-to recommendation from electricians. Better winding mechanism, 1/8" flexible steel, laser-etched markings. Costs more but lasts longer and works more reliably.

Southwire 50 ft Steel (FTS1/8-50): Tempered spring steel with laser markings, impact-resistant case. Similar price range to the Greenlee but more consistent quality reviews.

Greenlee FTS438-50 (50 ft): If you want to stick with Greenlee, their 50 ft professional-grade tape has better construction than this entry model. Worth the upgrade for regular use.

For DIY users doing a single project, the Greenlee 25 ft will likely work fine. For anything beyond occasional use, spending $20-40 more on a quality tape saves frustration and time.

The Bottom Line

The Greenlee 25 ft steel fish tape is a budget tool with budget limitations. It'll pull wire through a residential wall or attic space, and at under $20, the price is right for occasional DIY use. But the winding mechanism issues, excessive stiffness, and short length make it a poor choice for professional work or frequent use.

Greenlee makes excellent professional-grade fish tapes—this just isn't one of them. If you need a reliable fish tape for regular work, invest in a Klein, Southwire, or Greenlee's longer professional models. Your time is worth more than the $20-30 difference.

Check Current Price on Amazon →

Find Projects That Need This Tool

Looking for low voltage installation projects where quality tools matter?

LVN Signal surfaces low voltage installation projects from permit data before they hit bid boards.

→ Explore LVN Signal